banner2e top

Democrats Are Having the Wrong Debate About Working-Class Voters By Kevin Harris

Oct. 2, 2026

Kevin Harris

(TriceEdneyWire.com) - The 2026 midterm campaign is entering the final stretch. Democrats are poised for a big Election Night with the possibility of flipping both congressional chambers and several governorships. 

However recent polling from Politico shows some cause for concern. Democrats remain underwater with the working class voters they need. While more working class Americans trust Democrats over Republicans, Democrats still only hold a 6 point lead over the GOP.

The party is still way under a majority of support at just 38 percent. Fifty-five percent of Americans think politicians are just trying to win votes when they say they will help the working class, Politico found. This includes majorities who voted for Kamala Harris and Donald Trump. 

Democrats can’t afford to have their affordability message muffled by an internal fight over the party’s direction. The working class needs to hear a clear and direct message from Democrats on how the party will bring down costs. 

Should the party move left or toward the center? Should it embrace a more progressive economic program or emphasize moderation to win back working-class voters who have drifted away?

Those are real disagreements. But they obscure the more important question working class Americans want answered. Does the policy actually make working people better off?

That is a different test from whether a policy is progressive or moderate. Call it the paycheck test.

A policy passes the paycheck test when an ordinary worker can reasonably see how it leads to higher wages, more hours at decent pay, greater bargaining power, lower unavoidable expenses or more economic security. A political party passes the test when voters can connect what that party does in office with an improvement in their daily lives.

A progressive policy can be highly effective at raising living standards. Another progressive policy can be administratively cumbersome, poorly targeted or almost invisible to the people it is intended to help. The same is true of policies described as moderate. Some may produce tangible benefits while others may be politically cautious without producing much of anything.

The labels tell us where a proposal sits in an ideological debate. They do not tell us whether it works. That distinction matters because political ideology and economic effectiveness are not the same thing.

This is particularly important when thinking about working-class voters. Working class voters don’t care about left or right, progressive or moderate. They care about moving the economic needle in their own daily lives. They know what their paycheck buys. They know whether overtime is available. They know what rent costs, what groceries cost, whether health insurance feels affordable and whether a job that once supported a family still does.

They don’t care about the ideological packaging. Working class families want evidence that the government can make work pay. How that evidence is labeled is less important than if the policy actually works. 

The more useful question is what a policy actually accomplishes, not which faction of the party deserves credit. 

And, critically, can the government execute it?

That last question deserves more attention. A theoretically generous benefit that takes years to build, requires an expert to navigate or disappears into an obscure government agency that voters barely encounter may have very different political and economic consequences from one that shows up directly in a paycheck.

This does not mean that every government action needs to produce an immediate cash benefit. Governments build infrastructure, conduct scientific research, protect civil rights, regulate markets and provide public goods whose value cannot be measured by wages.

But to rebuild economic confidence among working Americans, direct results deserve special weight.

That reframes the progressive versus center intraparty argument. The choice should not be between a politics that is sufficiently progressive and one that is sufficiently moderate.

If a progressive proposal raises real wages, makes housing substantially cheaper or gives workers greater leverage over their employers, ideology matters less than results. If a centrist proposal expands employment and leaves families with meaningfully more disposable income, the same standard should apply.

There is also a communication lesson.

Democrats cannot permanently message their way around disappointing economic experiences. A slogan about opportunity is not a substitute for opportunity. A speech about affordability does not make housing affordable. Calling an economy strong does not persuade someone whose paycheck no longer covers the same groceries.

The most durable economic message is a policy result people can feel and experience in their daily life.

Democrats will continue to have disagreements between progressives and moderates. But disagreement cannot become a substitute for measuring outcomes.

To win back the working class, Democrats should remember that the more useful dividing line is not left versus center.

It is effective versus ineffective.

Kevin Harris is a Democratic strategist who has advised over 100 campaigns and ballot measures, including the past five presidential elections, served in the Obama Administration, as a cabinet member for two big city mayors and state attorney and Executive Director of the Congressional Black Caucus. 

 

Despite Fair Housing Victories in the Courtroom, HUD Seeks More Cuts By Charlene Crowell

 
September 03, 2026
 
Hope Policy Institute Black Mother and Child
Photo: Hope Policy Institute
  
(TriceEdneyWire.com) - Despite getting slapped down by three courts over this summer, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) still plans to continue its efforts to hobble fair housing investigations and enforcement. In late August, a federal judge warned that Congress – not federal agencies – authorizes and appropriates funding for programs and operations.
 
Noting on August 26 that “HUD failed to make “a satisfactory explanation for its decision," Judge Myong J. Joun ruled, “It belies credulity to think that five awards alone could broaden and strengthen fair housing work across the nation, and excluding almost all existing fair housing organizations will certainly not strengthen fair housing work. I cannot ignore this disconnect.”   
 
Judge Joun’s ruling rejected HUD’s attempt to limit grant criteria to only organizations with annual budgets of $5 million or more. That move would have had the effect of shrinking over 100 fair housing organizations to only five nationwide.  
 
In March 2025, a court ordered HUD to reinstate Fair Housing Initiatives Program (FHIP) grants it had terminated for more than 60 organizations. Later in June, yet another court ruled HUD must administer appropriated FHIP funds when the agency refused to disburse FHIP funds for the 2024 fiscal year. 
 
“When someone is wrongfully turned away from a housing opportunity because they have experienced domestic violence, because of a disability, their gender, or the color of their skin, they don’t call Washington,”, said Lisa Rice, President and CEO of the National Fair Housing Alliance (NFHA) reacting to the decision. “They call the fair housing organization in their community. HUD tried to shut the doors of the frontline groups who fight housing injustice and today a federal court emphatically said ‘no.'”   
 
Rice and other housing advocates still worry that this recent courtroom victory will be short-lived, as it only affects funding appropriated through the end of the current fiscal year, September 30.   
 
For the new fiscal year that begins October first, HUD has already made clear its intent to resume efforts to further diminish fair housing funding.   Its budget request of $68 million for Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity (FHEO) would continue recent fair housing cuts, this time by 21 percent. In 2024, Congress provided $86 million to fund FHEO, far below the $153 million needed to fully staff the division. As a result, FHEO now has only a third of the staff it had on January 20, 2025.  
 
Two other fair housing programs targeted for cuts are the Private Enforcement Initiative, which pays for the investigations and testing that prove discrimination happened, and the Education and Outreach Initiative, that funds efforts to ensure people know they have rights in the first place. 
 
These and other regressive actions will continue to be legally challenged by NFHA and its consortium of more than 290 private, nonprofit fair housing organizations; state and local civil rights agencies; and individuals throughout the United States. As it works to ensure every neighborhood has the resources people need to thrive and expand equitable housing opportunities for all people and communities, the organization also analyzes housing trends.  
  
 For example, NFHA’s most recent analysis of fair housing trends found that in 2024:  
  • From 2023 to 2024, housing discrimination complaints based on color increased 26.2 percent. 
  • Nationwide, 32,321 housing discrimination complaints were filed one of the highest figures in more than two decades.  
  • 83.56 percent of the year’s complaints were rental related.  
As only 44.7 percent of Blacks owned their homes in 2024, Black families are more likely to become rental victims of racial housing discrimination.    
The irony of these and other still unfolding events is that the agency designated to enforce the nation’s fair housing law is clearly demonstrating its determination to roll back over 60 years of hard-won civil rights.
 
NFHA’s analysis aptly summarizes why the fight for fair housing must continue: 
“In the U.S., place is inextricably linked to opportunity: where we live determines our access to fresh air, clean water, well-resourced schools, healthcare facilities, reliable transportation, good jobs, quality internet service, and much more. Meanwhile, too many people are stuck in places that impede— rather than promote—their ability to thrive. Millions of Americans struggle under the weight of excessive housing costs, a dearth of affordable housing supply, and a lack of resources and amenities in the communities where they live.”  
Charlene Crowell is a senior fellow with the Center for Responsible Lending. She can be reached at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it." data-linkindex="3">This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..   
 

Democrats Should Take Trump’s $5,000 Promise Seriously By Kevin Harris

Sept. 15, 2026

Kevin Harris

(TriceEdneyWire.com) - Donald Trump’s promise to send American adults a $5,000 “Trump Dividend” if Republicans retain control of Congress deserves more than ridicule from Democrats.

There are plenty of reasons to question the proposal. Trump has not provided a detailed mechanism for delivering the payments. Congress would have to act and Republicans themselves are divided over the idea. The estimated cost is well over $1 trillion, raising legitimate concerns about deficits, interest rates and inflation as the war in Iran rages on. Also, Republicans already control Congress and could simply act on this now if they wanted too. 

But Democrats should be careful not to assume that any of these facts matter to struggling Americans. 

Trump has repeatedly demonstrated an instinct for economic policies that are exceptionally easy for voters to understand and voters have consistently shown they don’t care about the details.

Consider “no tax on tips” and the Trump tariffs he campaigned on in 2024. 

The tariffs have failed and raised costs on working families while straining small businesses and rural America just as Democrats said they would. Taxpayers have lost more due to tariffs than have been collected from foreign governments despite Trump’s claims that America has taken in trillions of dollars in revenue. 

And similarly no tax on tips has not lived up to what was promised. Republicans enacted a temporary deduction for qualified tipped income as part of their 2025 tax legislation. The policy is more limited than the slogan suggests. Eligible workers can deduct up to $25,000 in qualified tips from federal taxable income but that’s subject to income limits, and payroll taxes still apply. That ultimately doesn’t put much income back into the pockets of workers who rely on tips to make ends meet. 

But politically, the simplicity of the messaging on tariffs and tips is the more important point. “No tax on tips” tells a waitress, bartender or other tipped worker immediately what Trump says he wants to do for them. And tariffs were the solution to the problem of foreigners “ripping off” American workers frustrated because their wages aren’t rising fast enough.

The $5,000 dividend takes tariffs and tips messaging another step further.

Trump is offering voters a proposition requiring almost no explanation. The message is simple. Republicans keep Congress and American adults get $5,000. 

Democrats should scrutinize the facts without getting so lost in the policy that their messaging misses the economic pain working class families are experiencing. 

Rather than mocking Trump, Democrats should ensure voters know what their plans are for direct economic relief. 

Even a bad Trump plan beats no plan from Democrats. 

Democrats should remember that the working class experiences the economy personally. They know what groceries cost. They know their rent or mortgage payment. They know what they earn every two weeks. They certainly understand what an additional $5,000 would mean to their household. And they are willing to take another chance on Trump because he’s put direct payments into their bank accounts before. 

During the COVID-19 crisis, Trump signed legislation authorizing direct payments of up to $1,200 per eligible adult, followed by another round of payments before he left office. The direct relief was wildly popular even as Americans were skeptical of Trump’s overall handling of the pandemic. 

Trump understands the political power of making economic policy concrete, even if there is no plan to actually get it done. 

“No tax on tips” is concrete. A COVID stimulus check is concrete. A $5,000 dividend is concrete. Tariffs are concrete. The fact that none of these policies are effective or realistic doesn’t matter. 

The lesson here is that Democrats need an economic agenda whose benefits voters can identify as readily as Trump’s.

If Democrats believe Trump’s $5,000 promise cannot be delivered, they should explain precisely why. If they believe it would worsen inflation or explode the deficit, they should make that case. But they also need to answer the question sitting underneath the appeal of Trump’s proposals which is how will Democrat policies put direct relief in the pockets of working families. 

The answer to Trump cannot be an academic political science course in how the payments will never happen, nor should Democrats laugh it off. 

Trump’s proposal may ultimately prove impossible to enact but that doesn’t eliminate the political appeal  to working class families who feel abandoned by the Democratic Party. 

That is the larger lesson of the COVID checks, tariffs, “no tax on tips” and now the proposed $5,000 Trump Dividend. 

Americans are deeply anxious about the cost of living and the party that can translate economic policy into benefits ordinary people can see, understand and feel has an important advantage in communicating its agenda.

Democrats should take that lesson seriously, even if they don’t take Trump’s $5,000 promise at face value.

Kevin Harris is a Democratic strategist who has advised over 100 campaigns and ballot measures, including the past five presidential elections, served in the Obama Administration, as a cabinet member for two big city mayors and state attorney and Executive Director of the Congressional Black Caucus. 

Introducing Our Congressional Blueprint to Bring Affordability for All By Marc H. Morial

To Be Equal 
September 14, 2026

Express written permission must be obtained from Mauri Solages Photography for usage

(TriceEdneyWire.com) - "The rich nations must use their vast resources of wealth to develop the underdeveloped, school the unschooled, and feed the unfed." - Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

It is a peculiar time in America, when economists offer varying outlooks on our economy. Some herald the artificial intelligence era as a period of great prosperity. The stock markets continue to climb, nearly unscathed by a war that costs the nation nearly $1 billion every day. And the current administration, despite firing the official overseeing the Bureau of Labor Statistics' monthly jobs report just over a year ago, says the job market shows signs of growth.

But for most Americans, the reality paints a much dimmer picture. 

This Iran war has cost the average household over $1,200 in the last seven months as gas prices reach record highs. Access to safe, affordable food is growing scarcer, with nearly weekly recalls on nutritious items. And as tariffs and global spats threaten energy prices as we enter the colder months, disastrous cuts to Medicaid, Medicare, and SNAP benefits loom on the horizon to pay for tax cuts for the wealthy in the Big Ugly Bill.

The Urban League movement sees the pain Americans face every day, and we’re meeting the moment the best way we can through job programs and housing and education supports, but now is also a time for Congress to act.

Less than two months ahead of the midterm elections, we’re no longer waiting on either side of the aisle to present an agenda that will serve the people. We’ve developed one ourselves.

I’d like to introduce our blueprint to rescue the American Dream and put working families first: the Affordability for All agenda.

This agenda is informed by research from our Washington Bureau, anecdotes from our affiliates, and insights from my leadership as President of the National Urban League for over 23 years. 

These are the six calls to action:

1. Pass a National Living Wage

No one who works full time should live in poverty. Raise the federal minimum wage to reflect today’s cost of living and index it to inflation so wages keep pace with rising costs. 

2. Repeal and Replace the Big Ugly Bill

H.R. 1, “the Big Ugly Bill,” represents one of the greatest threats to affordability for working families. Repeal its harmful cuts and restore investments in Medicaid, education, student aid, nutrition assistance, and other programs that help families succeed, not just survive. 

3. Housing Vouchers

Housing vouchers should work more like SNAP or Medicaid: if you qualify, you receive assistance. Fully fund the Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) program, so every eligible family can access safe, affordable housing while expanding pathways for homeownership. 

4. Launch a National Affordable Housing Trust

America cannot solve the housing crisis without dramatically increasing the supply of affordable homes. Establish a robust national Housing Trust Fund to finance the construction and preservation of affordable and workforce housing at the scale the crisis demands. 

5. Restore Affordable Internet Access

Reestablish and strengthen the Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP) so every family can afford broadband. In today’s economy, internet access is as essential as electricity for work, education, healthcare, and economic mobility.

6. End Inflationary Tariffs that Raise Costs

American families should not bear the cost of policies that make everyday goods more expensive. Repeal inflationary tariffs and replace them with trade policies that strengthen American competitiveness without driving up household costs. 

Our nation is facing an unprecedented crisis driven by unregulated technology that threatens to upend our workforce and education system. We have had enough of spending our resources on misplaced priorities and vanity projects for a President who has shown Americans time and time again that their livelihoods and future are not a priority. 

Now is the time to act. Now is the time to adopt the Affordability for All agenda and make America prosperous again.

A Nation That Forgets Its History Is Bound By Ben Jealous

 

benjealous pfaw

(TriceEdneyWire.com) - When we forget the first fights over voting rights, we forget who profits when the many are divided.

Voting rights is back in the news because some people are still trying to decide whose votes deserve trust. In Georgia, the Justice Department and FBI under President Donald Trump have reopened questions around Fulton County’s 2020 election records after agents seized hundreds of boxes of ballots. The Associated Press reports the FBI has assigned 260 analysts and operations staff to review them.

Fulton County includes most of Atlanta and sits at the heart of Georgia’s transformation. It has a large Black electorate, growing Latino and Asian American communities, and many newer residents drawn by the Atlanta region’s jobs and universities. It voted against President Trump. Yet Georgia’s 2020 result was not some partisan rumor. Local officials counted the ballots. The state counted them three times, including once by hand. Republican officials certified the result. Each count confirmed the same outcome. That matters because vote suppression has often followed the same pattern: discredit the voters, divide the people, deprive enough citizens of the ballot, and move power upward.

The country has largely forgotten one of its earliest broad voting rights victories: the campaign to end property qualifications for white men. In many states, a man could be white, free, taxed, armed and called to defend the Revolution — and still be denied the vote because he did not own enough property.

Those men did not suffer as long as Black men, women, Native people or others shut out of democracy. Their exclusion still reveals the old fault line. Power rightfully belongs to the people. Yet wealthy interests have often tried to keep too much of it for themselves.

Some people profit from our forgetting. If we forget that landless white men once had to fight for the vote, we can miss the pattern when it returns in new clothes.

Benjamin Franklin saw the absurdity. He told the story of a man whose vote depended on owning a jackass worth enough money to qualify him. When the animal died, the man lost the vote. Franklin asked the obvious question: “In whom is the right of suffrage? In the man or in the jackass?”

Thomas Paine gave the moral answer. “Man did not enter into society to become worse than he was before, nor to have fewer rights than he had before, but to have those rights better secured.”

There is irony in President Trump’s love of President Andrew Jackson. Jackson and his allies built the Democratic Party with a founding promise: government should answer to the landless many, not merely the propertied few.

Jackson’s democracy was badly bounded. It excluded Black people, women and Native people. His politics also embraced slaveholding white supremacy. Still, he saw one danger clearly. In his veto of the national bank, he warned that “the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes.”

That warning fits this moment. Vote suppression has often worked by discrediting voters, dividing working people against one another, and depriving the many of their full voice so some rich and powerful people can bend government toward themselves.

That was much of the logic of monarchy: divide and conquer. It was much of the logic of Jim Crow: tell poor white people their enemy is Black freedom. It was true in the 1820s. It was true in the 1920s, when immigrants from predominantly Catholic countries like Ireland and Italy were cast as threats to real America. It is true today, when immigrants from predominantly Catholic countries like Haiti and Mexico are made into scapegoats again. Tell rural voters their enemy is city voters. Tell Election Day voters their enemy is mail voters.

The tools change. The purpose often does not. Property requirements became poll taxes. Poll taxes became literacy tests. Literacy tests gave way to purges, ID rules, closed polling places and attacks on early voting, same-day registration and mail ballots.

The burden comes as paperwork, deadlines, long lines, missing names and ballots questioned after the people have spoken. A poll tax charged money. A long line charges time. Cutting early voting can tax people who do not control their schedules. Restricting mail ballots can tax seniors, disabled voters, rural voters and caregivers.

The Rev. Jesse Jackson spent his life widening the meaning of the many. He urged young people to hold “a diploma in one hand” and “a voter registration card in that other hand.” Education and the ballot. Knowledge and power.

I come to this history as a son of the Revolution, the abolitionist movement, and the Southern populist tradition that rose in the decades after the Civil War and united working men across color lines. My great-great-grandfather, Edward David Bland, was born enslaved and died a Virginia legislator.

He helped build the Readjuster Party, a post-Civil War, multiracial voting rights movement that brought together Black men who had been enslaved and white men who had fought for the Confederacy. Their cause was schools, fairer taxes, debt relief, voting rights and democracy. When they gained power, they abolished Virginia’s poll tax.

After they were broken, Virginia’s ruling Democrats wrote a new constitution in 1902 that brought the poll tax back with literacy tests and other barriers. Black voters were almost wiped out as a political force. White voting was cut roughly in half. The old ruling class knew whose coalition it was trying to prevent from rising again.

Imagine if every schoolchild learned that the poll tax was not only an attack on Black voting power but also on poor white voting power. We might see the trick more clearly when it returns in new clothes.

The Democratic donkey did not come from Franklin’s parable. It came from Jackson’s enemies calling him a jackass, an insult he embraced and cartoonists later made stick. Still, the echo is hard to miss.

If Democrats keep the jackass, they should remember Franklin’s question. The right was never in the jackass. It was never in the deed, the poll tax, the ID card, the Tuesday work schedule, the mailbox or the database.

The right is in the people. Every generation that won more democracy ultimately did so by resisting efforts by the few to divide the many. That is our work now: remember the history, reject the division, and defend the vote for every one of us.

Ben Jealous is a professor of practice at the University of Pennsylvania and former national president and CEO of the NAACP.

X